Merchants today are constantly looking for ways to offset rising credit card fees without alienating customers. For resellers, offering real strategies—not just another POS system—is the best way to stand out.
Two of the most effective solutions are cash discounting and surcharging. Each one helps businesses protect their margins, but they work very differently and make sense in different industries.
This guide will break down both strategies, compare pros and cons, and give you practical examples so you can decide which approach is right for your business—or help your merchants choose wisely.
Key Takeaways:
- Cash discounts reward customers for paying with cash and help merchants cut down credit card processing fees.
- Surcharges shift card costs directly to shoppers, keeping merchant margins stable.
- The right fit depends on your industry, transaction size, and customer habits.
- Modern POS systems like KORONA POS automate both strategies, giving merchants flexibility and resellers a powerful value-add.
What is a Cash Discount?
A cash discount rewards customers who pay with cash instead of a card. The merchant lists a standard price, then reduces it if cash is used.
Example use cases:
- Coffee shops & quick-service restaurants – shave $0.50 off a drink when paid in cash.
- Retail shops – take 3% off purchases at checkout.
- Gyms, salons, and local service providers – encourage upfront cash payments.
➡️ Merchant takeaway: Cuts processing costs, improves margins, and often feels like a “bonus” to customers.
➡️ Reseller takeaway: A simple pitch—“this POS system pays for itself by saving merchants on card fees.”
What’s a Surcharge?
A surcharge is the opposite: instead of rewarding cash, it passes card fees directly to customers. The listed price stays the same, but an extra fee (usually 2–4%) is added if a card is used.
This differs from a convenience fee, wherein a customer pays through an alternative channel that’s more convenient for them but costs the merchant more to process. For example, a movie theater may charge a small fee for buying tickets online instead of at the box office.
Example use cases:
- Contractors and service providers – add a 3% fee to large invoices.
- Airlines & utilities – widely use surcharges to offset card processing.
- Online retailers – protect slim margins where card use dominates.
➡️ Merchant takeaway: Protects profits on large or frequent card transactions.
➡️ Reseller takeaway: An upsell opportunity—“our POS applies surcharges automatically and keeps you compliant.”
PRO TIP!
Transparency is everything. Businesses must clearly disclose surcharges at checkout and on receipts to comply with card network rules and state laws.
Cash Discount vs. Surcharge: Quick Comparison
Feature | Cash Discount | Surcharge |
Definition | Price cut for cash | Fee added for card use |
Purpose | Incentivize cash, cut card fees | Offset card processing costs |
Customer Perception | Positive ("I saved money") | Risky if framed as a penalty |
Common Users | Cafes, local shops, small gyms | Airlines, utilies, contractors |
Visibility | Discount shown on receipt | Fee added at checkout |
Both strategies work, but choosing the right one depends on your business type, average transaction size, and customers’ preferred payment methods.
- Dual pricing shows two separate prices upfront: one for cash, one for card.
- Cash discounts and surcharges start with a single price and adjust it at checkout (either reducing it for cash or adding a card fee).
Pros and Cons of Cash Discounts
Cash discounts can enhance cash flow and reduce card processing fees, but require clear communication and adherence to legal regulations.
Pros | Cons |
Encourages cash payments | Legal considerations |
Customer relationship benefits | Cash handling risks |
Operational efficiency |
Pros of Cash Discounts
✅ Encourages Cash Payments
Cash discounts are especially helpful for high-volume, low-ticket businesses like coffee shops and quick-service restaurants. A small incentive nudges customers to pay with cash, cutting processing fees and improving margins over time.
✅ Customer Relationship Benefits
Customers tend to view discounts positively. Even small savings improve satisfaction and loyalty, especially when paired with loyalty programs or promotions.
✅ Operational Efficiency
Cash is sometimes faster to process than cards, reducing wait times during busy hours and lowering operational friction.
Cons of Cash Discounts
❌ Legal Considerations
Cash discounts are legal under federal law, but you must comply with state-specific rules. Clear signage at checkout is essential. Automated POS systems help ensure compliance by applying the discount consistently.
❌ Cash Handling Risks
More cash transactions mean more trips to the bank, higher theft risk, and the need for stronger cash management processes.
Pros and Cons of Surcharges
Surcharges allow businesses to lower their merchant fees, but they must be clearly communicated to avoid customer dissatisfaction. Legal compliance is critical, and POS systems can help manage both calculation and disclosure.
Pros | Cons |
Offsets credit card fees | Transparency and compliance |
Risk management | Customer perception |
Industry restrictions |
Pros of Surcharges
✅ Offsets Credit Card Fees
By passing credit card processing costs to the customer, you maintain your margins even when card usage is high. This is especially valuable for industries with high average ticket prices.
✅ Risk Management
Surcharges protect against unpredictable swings in processing fees, providing stability for businesses heavily dependent on card transactions.
Cons of Surcharges
❌ Transparency and Compliance
To comply with card networks and state laws, you must clearly disclose surcharges at checkout. Modern POS systems automatically calculate and display surcharges to keep you compliant.
❌ Customer Perception
If communicated poorly, surcharges can feel like a penalty. Transparent messaging and clear receipts are essential to maintaining customer trust.
❌ Industry Restrictions
Some industries, like cannabis dispensaries, often can’t accept card payments at all due to federal banking rules. In these cases, surcharges aren’t relevant — cash discounts or ATM-style solutions are more common.
Role of a POS System in Managing Discounts and Surcharges
While there are many types of POS systems out there, modern POS systems like KORONA POS automate the process, eliminating guesswork. The system instantly recognizes the payment method, applies the right discount or surcharge, and ensures accurate reporting every time.
With features like POS payments, self-checkout systems, and detailed reporting and analytics, businesses can streamline workflows while staying compliant with state and card network rules. Whether running a single location or a multi-store operation, automation ensures transparency and consistency across every transaction.
Free printable templates and checklists to help you manage retail operations with ease
Benefits of Using a POS System for Cash Discount & Surcharge
POS systems offer multiple advantages when managing payment strategies, providing efficiency, accuracy, and data-driven insights. By automating key processes and centralizing data, POS features simplify what could otherwise be a complex system of compliance, pricing, and customer communication.
Automated Calculations
KORONA POS automatically calculates the correct discount or surcharge at checkout, reducing staff error and saving valuable time. This ensures consistency across all transactions, no matter how busy the store gets. And with a cloud-based system like KORONA, you get integrated payments and the cheapest credit card processing available.
Enhanced Reporting
POS reporting enables businesses to track cash versus card transactions, analyze customer payment behaviors, and refine strategies for optimal profitability. With these insights, businesses can make data-backed decisions that improve margins and enhance long-term planning.
Discover Advanced Analytics and Custom Reports
Speak with a product specialist and learn how KORONA POS can work for your business.
Customer Transparency
Clear POS-generated receipts display discounts and surcharges, enhancing customer trust and minimizing confusion. This level of transparency also helps build stronger customer relationships by showing that your business values honesty and fairness.
Scalability and Adaptability
POS systems grow with your business. Whether you’re adding locations, integrating online sales, or offering mobile payments, modern POS software accommodates evolving business needs. This flexibility enables businesses to remain competitive in a rapidly evolving retail and hospitality landscape.
Compliance and Legal Security
Automated POS systems ensure that businesses comply with local and federal regulations when applying discounts or surcharges, thereby protecting them against fines and disputes. Built-in compliance tools also reduce the need for constant manual oversight.
Time Savings and Staff Training
Automated systems reduce training requirements and automate inventory management, allowing staff to focus on customer service rather than performing manual calculations. New employees can get up to speed faster, and existing staff can dedicate more attention to enhancing the customer experience.
Which Strategy Is Right for Your Business?
The right approach depends on your business model, industry, and customers. The right POS system gives you the flexibility to adapt, test, and refine your strategy for maximum profitability.
- Cash Discounts work best for cafés, small retailers, and gyms where customers are willing to pay with cash to save a few bucks.
- Surcharges shine in industries with larger transactions — contractors, service providers, online retailers — where card use is heavy.
➡️ Merchant Takeaway: weigh your transaction size and customer habits.
➡️ Reseller Takeaway: position yourself as the partner who helps merchants make the right call.
Simplify Your Payment Process with Our All-in-One POS System
Get started with KORONA POS today!
Explore all the features that KORONA POS has to offer with an unlimited trial. There’s no commitment or credit card required.
At the end of the day, both cash discounts and surcharges are about protecting your margins and keeping customers happy.
The smartest move? Choose a POS that automates the entire process with an all-in-one solution like KORONA POS. This provides transparency, compliance, data-driven insights, and the ability to compare credit card processing rates, all while saving your staff time at the register, regardless of whether you’re a small business or a multi-store operation.
